Dexter W. Stefonek was born January 31,
1918, in Rhinelander, Oneida Co., WI,
and died by being murdered November 19, 1985,
near Glendive, Dawson Co.,
MT, at age 67.
He is
the son of John Aleck Stefonek of Minnesota and
Ethel Schultz of Rhinelander, Oneida Co., WI.
Vivian E. Abbey was born November 17,
1905, in Rhinelander, Oneida Co., WI, and died
December 25, 1984, in Portland, Multnomah
Co., OR, at age 79.
She is
the daughter of Russel
Lewis
Abbey of Byron, Fond du Lac Co., WI, and
Agnes A. Schmidt of
the Village of Dorchester, Mayville Twp., Clark Co., WI.
Dexter W. Stefonek and
Vivian E. Abbey were married
December 15, 1940, in Rhinelander, Oneida Co., WI.
Dexter W. Stefonek and
Vivian E. (Abbey) Stefonek had one child:
-
David Michael
Stefonek: Born May 5, 1941, in
Rhinelander, Oneida Co., WI; Living. Married (1) June 1964 to Constance Jane
"Connie" Stephens: Born September 19, 1942, in Unknown; Living. Divorced. Married (2)
to Karen Rupert Unknown: Born February 1950 in Unknown; Living.
John Aleck Stefonek died March 3, 1928, in
Rhinelander, Oneida Co., WI.
Ethel
May (Schultz) Stefonek then married
Otis Melville Rude.
Otis Melville Rude was born November 29, 1895, in
Arlington, Volga, Brookings Co., SD, and died November 13, 1971, in Rhinelander, Oneida Co.,
WI, at age 75. He is
the son of Hans Christian Gullikson Rude of Nordstun Rud
Farm, Hurdal, Norway and Anna Marie Hatlestad of Beaver Twp., Fillmore Co., MN.
Otis Melville Rude married Georgia Coffield on
January 29, 1915, in Parker, Turner Co., SD.
Otis Melville Rude and Georgia Coffield had 6 children.
Georgia (Coffield) Rude died January 7, 1927, in
Rhinelander, Oneida Co., WI, at age 31, two days after the birth of her last
child.
Otis Rude and Ethel
May (Schultz) Stefonek were married
February 5, 1929, in
Rhinelander, Oneida Co.,
WI.
Otis Rude and Ethel
May (Schultz) (Stefonek) Rude had
one child:
-
Robert Gordon Rude: Born June 5, 1931, in
Rhinelander, Oneida Co., WI; Living.
TIMELINE
Otis Melville Rude was born November 29,
1895, in Volga, Brookings Co., SD.
Vivian E. Abbey was born November 17, 1905,
in Rhinelander, Oneida Co., WI.
The 1910 U. S. Census taken on
April 30, 1910, shows John Schulz (age 36) born in Ohio to Polish German-born parents is a
Teamster at a Saw Mill who owns his home free of a mortgage and is living at 312
North Stevens Street, 2nd Ward, City of Rhinelander, Oneida Co.,
WI. Living with him is his wife of 11 years, Rosie Schultz (age 32) born in Wisconsin to
German-born parents, with all three of the children born to her still alive. Also living there
are his three children, all born in Wisconsin to Wisconsin-born parents: Steven
J. Schultz (age 10); Lucy M. Schultz (age 8); and Jennie Schultz (age 4).
The New North,
Rhinelander, Oneida Co., WI, Thursday, November 22, 1917
TRANSFERS
John Schultz and wf. to John Stefonek
Ld Ct, of N1/2 of Lot 5 blk 5 of Alban's 2nd Add to Rhinelander - $700.
Dexter W. Stefonek was born January 31,
1918, in Rhinelander, Oneida Co., WI.
The 1920 U. S. Census taken on January 7, 1920, shows Russell
Abbey (age 38) born in Wisconsin to Canadian and Wisconsin-born parents is an
Automobile alesman owing his home at 416 Rib Street, Rhinelander, Oneida Co.,
WI. Living with him is his wife Anna Abbey (age 36) born in Wisconsin to
Wisconsin-born parents. Also living there is their daughter Vivian Abbey (age
14) born in Wisconsin of Wisconsin-born parents.
The 1920 U. S. Census taken on January 12, 1920,
shows John Stefonek (age 28) born in Minnesota to United States-born parents is
employed and living at 532 North Stevens Street, 2nd Ward, City of Rhinelander,
Oneida Co., WI. Living with him is his wife Ethel Stefonek (age 28) born in
Wisconsin to Minnesota-born parents. Also living there is son, Dexter Stefonek
(age 1-10/12) born in Wisconsin to Minnesota and Wisconsin-born parents. A
Boarder, Mahon (age 21) also lives in the house.
The 1930 U. S. Census taken on April 19, 1930, shows Russell L.
Abbey (age 47) born in Wisconsin to Canadian and New York-born parents is an
acid maker in a paper mill owing his home at 416 Rib Street, Third Ward,
Rhinelander, Oneida Co., WI. Also living there is his wife Anna A. Abbey (age
45) born in Wisconsin to Wisconsin-born parents. They were married at ages 22
and 20, respectively. Their two unmarried children born in Wisconsin are living
at home: Vivian Abbey (age 24) who a
saleslady at a store, and Truman Abbey (age 10).
The 1930 U. S. Census taken on April 17, 1930, shows
Otis Rude (age 35) born in South Dakota to Norwegian and Minnesota-born parents
and first married at age 20 is a General Farmer owning his own farm valued at
$2,700 and living on 607 Alison Road, 3rd Ward, City of Rhinelander, Oneida Co.,
WI. Living with him is his wife Ethel Rude (age 34) born in Wisconsin to
Minnesota-born parents who was first married at age 19. Living at home are Otis Rude's children: Velma Rude (age 14) born in South Dakota to South Dakota-born
parents; Otis Rude (age 12) born in South Dakota to South Dakota-born parents;
June Rude (age 9) born in Wisconsin to South Dakota-born parents; Kenneth Rude
(age 8) born in Wisconsin to South Dakota-born parents; and Darrel D. Rude (age
7) born in Wisconsin to South Dakota-born parents. Also living there are the
step-children of Otis, both born in Wisconsin to Wisconsin-born parents: Dexter
W. Stefonek (age 12); and Walter A. Stefonek (age 7).
Dexter W. Stefonek and
Vivian E. Abbey were married
December 1940 in Rhinelander, Oneida Co., WI.
The Rhinelander Daily
News,
Rhinelander, Oneida Co., WI, Tuesday, June 13, 1967
Mrs. Otis Rude, Former Mail Carrier,
Dies
Mrs. Otis Rude, Sr., 70, Rte. 1, a
resident of the Rhinelander area all her life and a former rural mail carrier
and practical nurse, died at 2:05 a. m. today in St. Mary's Hospital after an
illness of one year. Her home was in the town of Newbold. The former Ethel May
Schultz was born in the town of Pine Lake Feb. 9, 1897, and she was raised in
that town. She attended Rhinelander High School and in 1916 was married to John
Stefonek, who was a rural mail carrier on Old Route 1, which covered the
Crescent Flats region. After Mr. Stefonek's death she continued as the carrier
on the same route until she married Otis Rude Sr. in 1929. She then worked as a
practical nurse in the Rhinelander area for many years, retiring when Mr. Rude
did in 1957. They spent the winters in Florida since then. She was a member of
the Trinity Lutheran Church and the Crescent Woman's Club. Surviving are her
husband, Otis Rude Sr.; three sons, Dexter Stefonek of Rhinelander, Walter
Stefonek of Illinois and Robert Rude of St. Paul; two stepsons, Otis Rude Jr. of
Rhinelander and Darrel Rude of Milwaukee; one stepdaughter, Mrs. Francis (June)
Whittier of Wisconsin Rapids; one sister, Mrs. Catherine Auvil of Rhinelander;
one brother, James Schultz of Rhinelander; 16 grandchildren and one
great-grandchild. She was preceded in death by her first husband; one son,
Harold Stefonek; one stepson, Kenneth Rude; one stepdaughter, Mrs. Louis (Velma)
Hamilton, and two brothers, Charles and John Schultz. Funeral services will be
held at 1 p. m. Thursday in the Trinity Lutheran Church, with the Rev. Walter A.
Olson officiating. Burial will be in St. Mary's Cemetery. Friends may call at
the Carlson Funeral Home after 3 p. m. Wednesday and Thursday until 11 a. m.
The Rhinelander Daily
News,
Rhinelander, Oneida Co., WI, November 15, 1971
OBITUARIES
Otis Rude Sr.
Otis Rude, Sr., 75, Rhinelander, died
Saturday at the Friendly Village. He was born Nov. 29, 1895, in Arlington, S.
Dak. and was raised there moving to Rhinelander in 1919. He was employed by the
Juday and Willis for many years and also worked in the shipping department of
Daniels Mfg. until his retirement in 1958. Survivors include: one daughter, Mrs.
Francis (June) Whittier of Wisconsin Rapids; three sons, Otis, Jr. of
Rhinelander, Darrell of Milwaukee and Robert of White Bear Lake, Minn.; two step
sons, Dexter and Walter Stefonek, both of Rhinelander; one brother, Norman Rude
of Albuquerque, New Mex.; one sister, Mrs. Agnes Asborne of Sioux Falls, S. Dak.;
16 grandchildren and 5 great-grandchildren. Funeral services will be 1 p. m.
Tuesday in the Carlson Funeral Home with the Rev. Arnold W. Vocke officiating.
Interment will be in the St. Mary's Cemetery. Friends may call at the funeral
home after 4 p. m. today and Tuesday until the hour of service.
Vivian E. (Abbey) Stefonek died
December 25, 1984, in Portland, Multnomah
Co., OR at age 79.
The Rhinelander Daily
News,
Rhinelander, Oneida Co., WI, January 4, 1985
Vivian Stefonek
Vivian Abbey Stefonek, 79, of
Rhinelander, died Dec. 25 in Portland, Ore. She was born in Rhinelander Nov. 17,
1905. Mrs. Stefonek married Dexter Stefonek Dec. 15, 1940. She is survived by
her husband; one son, David; and two granddaughters, Karen and Krista. A
memorial service for Mrs. Stefonek will be held Monday at 2 p. m. at the
Rhinelander Seventh-Day Adventist Church.
Our Town,
Rhinelander, Oneida Co., WI, January 6, 1985
VIVIAN STEFONEK, 79, formerly of
Rhinelander, died Tuesday, December 25, 1984, in Portland, Oregon. April 3,
1987. She was born November 17, 1905. Survivors include her
husband, Dexter; son, David; and granddaughters, Karen and Krista. A memorial
service will be held Monday, January 7, 1985, at 2 p. m., in the Rhinelander
Seventh Day Adventist Church.
Dexter W. Stefonek died
November 19, 1985, in Glendive, Dawson Co.,
MT, at age 67.
The Rhinelander Daily
News,
Rhinelander, Oneida Co., WI, November 21, 1985
Rhinelander man missing in Montana
GLENDIVE, Mont. - The Dawson County,
Mont., sheriff's office Wednesday issued a missing person's report on Dexter
Stefonek, 67, of Rhinelander, whose car was found destroyed by fire Tuesday west
of Glendive. Stefonek was alone when he left Portland, Ore., Monday, the
sheriff's office reported. His car, a 1964 Plymouth, was found engulfed in
flames about noon Monday at a rest area along Interstate 94. Origin of the fire
is suspicious, the sheriff's office said. Stefonek was described as about
5-foot-6, with curly blond hair, blue eyes and wearing glasses.
The Rhinelander Daily
News,
Rhinelander, Oneida Co., WI, April 3, 1986
Dexter Stefonek
Memorial services will be 4 p. m.
Saturday at the Seventh Day Adventist Church with Rev. Clinton Maharry
officiating for Dexter Stefonek, 67, of Rhinelander who died in November of
1985. Burial will be in the Forest Home Cemetery. Stefonek was born January 31,
1918 in Rhinelander. He is survived by one son, David, of Corbett, Oregon; a
brother, Walter, of Fruitland Park, Florida; a step-sister, June Hartt of Mesa,
Arizona; two step-brothers, Otis Rude, Jr., of Rhinelander and Darrell Rude, of
Milwaukee; one half-brother, Robert Rude of St. Paul, Minnesota, and two
grandchildren. Stefonek was born and raised in Rhinelander and was a lifelong
resident. He married the late Vivian Abbey of Rhinelander. He was employed by
the Rhinelander Paper Company and was a member of the Seventh Day Adventist
Church. Carlson Funeral Home is in charge of the arrangements.
Our Town,
Rhinelander, Oneida Co, WI, April 6, 1986
DEXTER STEFONEK, 67, of Forest Lane
Road, Rhinelander, died November 1985, in Montana. He is survived by his son,
David, of Corbett, Oregon; stepsister, June Hartt of Mesa, Arizona; two step
brothers, Otis Rude Jr. of Rhinelander and Darrell Rude, of Milwaukee; half
brother, Robert Rude of St. Paul, MN, nephew, Dennis Stefonek; and two
grandchildren. The Rev. Clinton Meharry officiated at the funeral services held
April 5, 1986 at the Seventh Day Adventist Church. Burial is in Forest Home
Cemetery. He was raised in Rhinelander and was a lifelong resident. He graduated
from Rhinelander High School and married the late Vivian Abbey. She preceded him
in death on December 25, 1984. He was employed by the Rhinelander Paper Company
until his retirement. He was a member of the Seventh Day Adventist Church.
(Carlson Funeral Service, Inc).
I just watched this case on crystaldawn's DVDs volume 2.
There's something "off" about this one, and I can't quite put my finger on it.
kadrmas15's suggestion that it was a serial killer certainly seems to be the
conclusion that would make the most sense, but there is a lot that is unusual
about this one.
For those who haven't seen it in awhile, a brief summary: a depressed old man
named Dexter Stefonek
is out in Oregon basically living with his son, but as the first anniversary of
his wife's death approaches, he longs to return home to Wisconsin. One day, in
the middle of winter, he begins the 2,000 mile journey. The next evidence found
of the man is his car, burning at a rest stop. He is not inside. Witnesses at
the rest stop include its caretaker and a highway maintenance worker. When the
caretaker arrived, a white truck with green trim and Arizona plates was parked
in the rest stop area. There was no one around. This was around 8 AM. Next, a
highway worker stopped into the rest stop, and he too saw the truck, but now
Dexter Stefonek's car is present. Again, there is no sign of the old man, but
there is a younger man carrying what appear to be two milk jugs of gasoline. He
explains to the highway worker that he ran out of gas. The next thing
eyewitnesses report is Dexter's car ablaze, with the white truck nowhere to be
found.
Three months later, at a remote dump site some distance away from the rest stop,
some of Dexter's belongings are found scattered about, including his driver's
license and a suitcase with money in it. Eventually, underneath an old mattress,
Dexter himself is found. Dexter is thought to have been dead and in the location
for the previous three months (based on the level of decomposition, no doubt),
but his belongings, according to the people who regularly looked after the dump
site, were not there until the week they were discovered.
This leads to the important question: where were Dexter Stefonek's belongings
during the three "missing" months? And why had the killer come back to dump them
so long after the murder, but without having taken money that was in the
suitcase, despite having held on to the suitcase for three months?
These are the questions Stack rhetorically asks, of course, but I think there
are simpler answers than the segment makes out. What makes the most sense is
that everything (the body and Dexter's belongings) were dumped at the same time,
buried under a pile of other junk. Someone came along and began to pick through
the dump, pulling out and finding the various items, before finally coming
across Dexter's body. This person got scared and left without notifying
authorities (probably because he was illegally at the dump site), scattering
some of the stuff he had picked through in the process. Perhaps it was further
scattered by stiff plains winds.
What does not make sense to me, however, is what the killer was doing precisely.
Why would he evidently wait in a rest stop for somebody, commandeer his car,
drive it off somewhere, murder its original occupant and dump his body and
belongings, then come back and switch back to his original car, burning the
hijacked car in the process? Robbery was not a motive, because the suit case had
not been picked through enough to discover the money that was inside it. If the
killer truly was out of gas (quite possible), what would drive him to kill
somebody just to get control of his vehicle long enough to go get gas?
What bothers me is the motive seems so trivial, and the resulting cover-up of
the crime so necessarily elaborate, and all for what? It almost makes me wonder
if Dexter was followed from some location for some reason, until he pulled over
into the rest stop. Perhaps road rage, an incident out on the highway? It just
doesn't make much sense to kill the first guy who comes along, then go to all
that trouble to dump the body and burn the car, over MAYBE getting a little
gasoline. There was no sex crime here, from what the segment gave to us as
details, so the motive is truly obscure.
First aired:
4/12/1989
Cases include:
Unexplained Death: A trip from Oregon to Wisconsin goes awry
when Dexter Stefonek's car is found engulfed in flames in
Montana. His body was later found dumped in a remote
landfill; he had been shot twice in the head.
Dexter Stefonek set out to drive across country back to his
home after a visit with his son. His body was later found in a dump site and his
car set on fire. Who is responsible and why would they target this seemingly
defenseless old man?
Dexter Stefonek: Elderly man set to drive home after a
visit with his relatives was later found murdered and his car set on fire.
Searching for killer.
Recent Deaths
Beverly A. Hanson
Beverly A. Hanson, 49, of South Elgin passed away Friday, March 12, 2004 in her
home. She was born on May 8, 1954 in Belvidere, Illinois, the daughter of Walter
and Alice (Fish)
Stefonek. Beverly was a
loving daughter, wife, mother and grandmother, and will be dearly missed.
Graduate of Larkin High School in 1972. A member of Highland Avenue Church of
the Brethren.
Survivors include her husband, Frank of South Elgin; three children, John
Thomas, Jessica Perkins and Rebecca Combs; two step children, Michele and Dave
Hanson; three grandchildren, Simmia Pearson, Michael Pearson and Coral Combs;
two brothers, Dennis (Josie) and Scott Stefonek; a sister, Diane
(Norman) Dowlen; and many nieces and nephews.
She was preceded in death by her parents; and her brother, Steven
Stefonek.
Funeral services will be held on Wednesday at 2 PM in the Laird Funeral
Home, Elgin with Rev. Carl Myers officiating. Burial will be private. Visitation
will be on Wednesday from 12 Noon until the time of services in the funeral
home. Memorials may be made to the Make A Wish Foundation.
Beverly A. Hanson of South Elgin Funeral services for Beverly A. Hanson, 49,
of South Elgin, will be held at 2 p.m. Wednesday, at the Laird Funeral Home, 310
S. State St., Elgin. The Rev. Carl Myers will officiate. Born May 8, 1954, in
Belvidere, the daughter of Walter and Alice (nee Fish),
Stefonek, she passed away
Friday, March 12, 2004, at her home. Burial will be private. Beverly was a
graduate of Larkin High School in 1972 and a member of the Highland Avenue
Church of the Brethren. She was a loving daughter, wife, mother, and grandmother
and will be dearly missed. Survivors include her husband, Frank of South Elgin;
children, John Thomas, Jessica Perkins and Rebecca Combs; stepchildren, Michele
and Dave Hanson; grandchildren, Simmia Pearson, Michael Pearson and Coral Combs;
brothers, Dennis (Josie) and Scott Stefonek; sister, Diane
(Norman) Dowlen; and many nieces and nephews. In addition to her parents, she
was preceded in death by a brother, Steven Stefonek. Visitation will
be from noon until the time of services Wednesday, at the funeral home.
Memorials may be made to Make-A-Wish Foundation. Friends may visit
www.dailyherald.com/obits to express condolences and sign the guest book. For
funeral information, (847)741-8800.
Published in the Chicago Suburban Daily Herald from 3/14/2004 -
3/15/2004.
The Victim
Dexter was born January
31, 1918. He married Vivian Abbey, and the couple moved to
Oregon. On Christmas Day 1984, Vivian died. Dexter was
heartbroken, and moved in with his son David in Wisconsin,
staying for almost a year. However, he became despondent as the
one year anniversary of her death approached, and left his son's
home in Wisconsin and elected to drive the 2000 miles to his
home in Oregon. He told his son he would save time by not
stopping at motels, but by spending nights at rest stops in his
Plymouth Horizon.
The Murder
On the morning of
November 19, 1985, witnesses report a white Chevrolet 4X4 with a
wide horizontal blue stripe, Arizona plates and a Phoenix plate
holder sitting at the Bad Route Rest Area, in Glendive Montana,
a city in Dawson County, close to 8 A.M. Soon, a light
complected, clean shaven man in his mid thirties to early
forties arrived in Dexter's car. He was carrying two large jugs
full of gasoline. He claimed he had needed the gas for his truck
to a highway maintenance official, who then proceeded to leave
the man alone. An hour or so later, Dexter's car was found in
flames at the rest area. Gasoline was used as an accelerant, but
no other clues were found as to the whereabouts of Dexter.
The Body
Four months later, a
local couple dumping trash at a remote landfill seventeen miles
from the rest area discovered the wallet of Dexter Stefonek,
along with his suitcase, toiletry kit, boot, and various other
clothes and traveling paraphernalia belonging to him. These
items seemed out of place in the dump, and in the course of
searching for additional things like them, the couple stumbled
upon the body of Dexter Stefonek. He had been shot twice in the
head, and was concealed under a mattress. Oddly, investigators
determined that the body had been in the dump for the entire
four month span since the murder, while locals maintained that
Dexter's belongings had been there for less than a week before
the discovery of the body. While it is possible that it is a
coincidence and the items were there all along and no one found
them because they were covered up in the dump, possibly
unearthed by someone too nervous to report the body. Of course,
it is probable that the suspect had them the whole time, since
no one reported finding them beforehand.
Theories
The official theory of
the murder is that the suspect was already at the rest stop when
Dexter arrived, sometime around 7 A.M. The suspect then
carjacked Dexter, taking him to an unidentified location and
killing him, then taking his car back to the rest stop, torched
it to cover up evidence of the crime, then left in his truck.
The suspect has only
been identified by the rough physical details about him, the
description of his truck, and a line of graffiti etched into the
wall of the men's bathroom of the rest stop. It refers to a
shooting, the state of Wisconsin (Dexter's home state), the
month and year of the killing, and other details not released by
law enforcement. The graffiti writer referred to himself as 'Hot
Jock', which police postulate is a CB handle.
The seemingly motiveless
nature of the crime (Money in Dexter's briefcase was untouched,
so robbery seems to have been unlikely) has caused investigators
to suspect the case is one involving a serial killer, or some
other kind of psychopath killing purely for thrill. It is
recommended that you contact your local law enforcement if you
have any information.
|